Choosing Between Metal and Asphalt Shingle Roofing

When considering a new roof, your first thought may be: which material do I choose? Metal and asphalt are the two main choices, although asphalt is traditionally the more popular option throughout the country. Both have their own pros and cons, so it’s up to you to do thorough research before you make a decision.

If you’re still not sure which one to go with after reading this guide, consult with a trusted roofer in Burlington NC to get advice.

Metal Roofing: Pros, Cons and Characteristics

Metal roofing is a more complex option than asphalt shingles, as it requires specific techniques, experienced installers, and more components for successful installation. Metal roofing is a great option for North Carolina, though, because it resists extreme weather conditions and can last much longer than asphalt shingles – up to 50 years longer if well cared for.

Pros of Metal Roofing

Lightweight – This makes it easier for installers to handle and transport during the installation process. Plus, it won’t put unnecessary stress on your home, reducing the potential for frame damage.

Longevity – Metal roofing has a long lifespan -- 50+ years when properly cared for. Copper and zinc can actually last 100 years or more!

Lower Long-Term Cost – While metal roofing is more expensive initially to install, it lasts much longer and can outlast at least three asphalt shingle roofs.

Fire Resistance – Metal roofing is Class A fire-rated and non-combustible.

Weather Performance – Metal is the strongest and most durable roofing material when it comes to withstanding extreme weather conditions, such as strong wind, driving rain, hail, ice, snow, cold and heat.

Environmentally Friendly – Metal is highly recyclable.

Energy Efficiency – Metal roofing is cool roofing, meaning it absorbs heat in higher temperatures while retaining heat in cooler temperatures.

Increased Property Value – You can get more money for a home with metal roofing.

Low Maintenance – Metal roofs require minimal maintenance. You just have to worry about general upkeep such as removing leaves, branches, and other debris.

Color Availability – Metal comes in any color of the rainbow.

Cons of Metal Roofing

Higher Initial Cost – You will spend more money at first to install metal roofing than shingle roofing. The materials cost more and the labor costs more.

Limited Qualified Contractors – Locating a contractor who is qualified and experienced in metal roofing installation is not as easy as it is for a shingle installer.

More Labor Intensive – Metal roofing calls for a more precise installation than shingles, which is why you need a trained craftsperson. Installation takes more time as a result.

Appearance – Metal is thought by many to have more of an industrial look.

Shingle Roofing: Pros, Cons and Characteristics

Shingle roofs are the most common type in this country, mainly due to their affordability and availability of materials.

Pros of Shingle Roofing

Economical Over Short Term – Shingle roofs are cheaper than metal roofs upfront, but they don’t last as long as metal (20 years vs. 50+).

Easy Installation and Replacement – Shingles are less time and labor intensive, which means it’s a quicker and easier job.

Less Expensive Repairs – If you ever need a repair or replacement, shingles are easier and cheaper to fix.

More Qualified Installers – It’s easier to find a qualified shingle roof installer.

Cons of Shingle Roofing

Short Lifecycle – Most shingle roofs only last about 25 years on the high end.

Heavier – Asphalt shingles are actually heavier than metal roofing, which can add stress to the structure of your home.

Holds Heat – Asphalt shingles attract heat due to the dark colors that absorb warmth. This means your HVCAC system has to work harder to keep the interior temperatures comfortable.

Flaking Granules – The granules on shingles can shed and accumulate in your gutters, where they can cause a clog. As those granules fall off, they detract from the effectiveness of the shingle.

Contact Redeem Roofing

Whether you choose asphalt shingle or metal roofing, contact us today for a free quote and consultation. Our Burlington NC roofers would be happy to assist you.

We were very happy with the professionalism of Redeem Roofing. They patiently answered all of our questions and completed the work in a neat and timely fashion. We would definitely recommend them to others. - by Kathy H